About
Welcome to Art's Varsity Pizza, a beloved culinary gem located at 2822 Main St, Anderson, IN 46016. This establishment has become a staple in the local community, known for its deliciously crafted pizzas and hearty sandwiches. With a strong commitment to quality and flavor, Art's Varsity Pizza prides itself on using only the finest ingredients, ensuring that every bite delivers a burst of taste that keeps customers returning for more.
As you venture into Art's Varsity Pizza, the aroma of freshly baked dough and rich tomato sauce greets you like an old friend. The menu boasts a variety of options that cater to all palates, including their signature Poppies Pizza, a delightful combination of Italian sausage, pepperoni, ham, and bacon, all piled atop a perfectly baked crust. Vegetarian options, such as the Veggie Pizza, featuring mushrooms, green peppers, onions, and fresh tomatoes, are also available for those seeking lighter fare.
Don't forget to explore the sandwich selection, where delights like the Italian Roast Beef made from tender slow-cooked roast beef in a flavorful broth stand out. Customers rave about the loaded fries and boneless wings as well, each dish thoughtfully prepared to elevate your dining experience.
The reviews speak volumes about the exceptional quality at Art's Varsity Pizza. Loyal patrons like Tammie Sylvester share passionate testimonials, traveling miles just to savor their beloved pizza. Others like Billy Dodd attest to the unparalleled taste, calling it the best pizza they've ever had. The consistency in flavor and preparation has earned Art's Varsity Pizza a reputation that stretches far beyond Anderson.
The heart and soul of this establishment lie in its atmosphere and staff. Owner Michael Carter and his team create a welcoming environment that feels like home, where you're greeted with smiles and enthusiasm every time you walk through the door. It's clear that they are dedicated not just to serving food, but to creating lasting memories with their community through each meal.
So whether you're a local or just passing through, make sure to stop by Art's Varsity Pizza. Enjoy the fusion of flavors, the warmth of the atmosphere, and the excitement of discovering a true Anderson treasure. Your taste buds will thank you!
“ Live all the way on the South side of indinapolis grew up in Anderson love my Main Street Arts they always do me right I bring containers and pay per sandwich and bring it back to Indianapolis. Always get a pizza too. Michael and Michelle Carter are what's up!!!! If you've never tried them you're missing out. ”
“ Most unique & best tasting pizza. The combination of ingredients in the tomato sauce, cooking temperature, and even the toppings seam to have an added flavor of its own. ”
“ Been away for a few years. .STILL BEST PIZZA ANYWHERE. I live in Florida now and not a single place can come close to this. The BEEF, THE PIZZA, THE PEOPLE. THE BEST ”
“ Arts on main st best pizza all around i driv from out of town just to get there pizza on main st they are so much better then pizza king or any other pizza I will drov 30 mins or so just to get one ”
“ Very very good roast beef. Very very tender. Staff is great. It's a slice of the best parts of Anderson. There homemade sausage is the best I've ever tasted. A 10 out of 10. Absalutely amazing.Deep fried mushrooms were very well done also. The jalapeno poppers are a must try with diced jelepino and the best quality cheddar cheese. Come visit Mike if your ever in Anderson. It will be a mistake if you don't. You heard it here. ”
“ By far the best pizza and garlic bread around! 10/10 recommend ”
“ Ordered a 20" around the world, a little pricey.... .... But well worth it. Best pizza in Anderson I'm from Chicago, I have pizza knowledge ”
“ I love Arts! We went this afternoon right after opening and he didn't have roast beef - which is the best. A cute little kid convinced us that the sausage sandwich was the best. The owner shared that they make their own sausage and pizza dough. I have to tell you- that was a great sandwich! Of course the 'Round the World' pizza was awesome as usual! Thanks Arts! ”